Lady Bird is good, so Devin and I talked about why.
One of the essential functions of popular culture is to provide relief from the stresses of everyday life. Another is to offer thrills, joy and insights from unfamiliar perspectives. Here’s a sampling of moments from this year that accomplished those goals for me. Happy Thanksgiving.
A few people who know me know that I love Kanye West’s “Bound 2.” For those reading this, congratulations — you now have something in common with those good people.
I can’t entirely justify my love for this song, which arrives at the end of West’s aggressive, oppressive 2013 album Yeezus like a splash of cold water on a humid summer day. The rest of that album is striking and nasty; “Bound 2” is bracing and cuddly.
Happiness doesn’t come cheap. For many outside the privileged class, the price is prohibitively high. Those in the privileged class glance at this inescapable truth and wonder, with little intent to follow up, what they might do to subvert it.
The Florida Project — directed by the increasingly essential filmmaker Sean Baker, who also co-wrote the script with Chris Bergoch — trains its eye on the darkest corners of that tension. Its characters live, almost literally, in the shadow of Orlando, Florida’s Walt Disney World — known to its legions of visitors and admirers as “the happiest place on earth.” That golden sheen doesn’t stretch so far, though, and what lies beyond it is often ugly. To its credit, The Florida Project works hard to find a few bright spots amid that ugliness. It’s a complicated portrait that neither moralizes nor equivocates.
The film unfolds across one summer for restless six-year-old Moonee (Brooklynn Prince), who lives with her mother Halley (Bria Vinaite) in the Magic Castle Motel in Orlando, a brightly colored but sloppily maintained facility that serves as home for some of Orlando’s most impoverished. Its occupants, who have to switch rooms every so often to avoid establishing legal residency, can barely muster a grunt at broken laundry machines, splattered paint and cramped surroundings. For the viewer of means, this place appears a travesty. The characters have already made their peace: It’s home.
Moonee frolics with her friends through grubby parking lots and past tacky gift stores. She collects free breakfast scraps from Halley’s friend and upstairs neighbor Ashley (Mela Murder), a waitress at Waffle House. Moonee’s merry band of rabblerousers solicits coins from customers at a nearby ice cream store and gawks at the motel’s most promiscuous resident as she lounges topless by the pool. They spit, curse, fight and laugh. They’re kids.
So are the adults, sometimes. Halley whines a lot, and seems to encourage some of Moonee’s most regrettable tendencies. She’s taken to sex work as her only reliable source of income. Vinaite, a neon-haired and heavily tattooed Instagram star in her first movie role, doesn’t flinch from Halley’s self-absorption and self-destruction, but she commits so fully to those qualities that they become perversely endearing. There’s tenderness behind Vinaite eyes, though it never makes its way to her mouth.
By contrast, the events unfolding onscreen in The Florida Project are often visually exuberant, especially when the kids run amok. They know of no other life than their own, and they behave as if they have all they could want.
But even at its sweetest, the movie’s core is unmistakably rotten. Baker relies on wide shots of Florida’s vast blue sky and the area’s gaudy storefronts to speak what the characters don’t: This place’s pleasures, such as they are, hide the constant threat of upheaval.
Even the most noble intentions can’t paper over layers of trauma, heartbreak and resigned disappointment. Motel manager Bobby (Willem Dafoe) remains patient in the face of harsh insults from his residents; it’s striking and comforting to see Dafoe sans villainous posturing. He could so easily be a menace, impeding the residents’ already uncomfortable lives. But he’s just doing his job, striving to be lenient towards people for whom leniency is at times their only currency.
So much of this movie, which glides on the slow, humid passage of time, relies on the vibrancy of inexperienced actors, many underage. As in Tangerine, Baker’s excellent feature shot entirely on an iPhone, the cast is almost entirely unknown and largely amateur. The young ones behave so convincingly their age that it’s difficult to categorize their achievement as “acting.” But there’s truth in their work, as with the adults, who have natural chemistry and even some perverse comedic timing.
By the end, though, laughter drains out of the movie like the color in a young girl’s face. The Florida Project climaxes abruptly at a final image that’s as unsettling as it is inevitable. The last fifteen minutes are harrowing, and Baker offers no relief before cutting to a silent credits sequence.
What’s most striking is what’s left unsaid: Though the specter of Mickey Mouse hangs over everything, characters only utter the “D-word” a few times. For a movie that thumbs its nose at but can’t quite denounce American fantasies, this approach makes perfect sense. There’s no reason to put into words what’s already in the air.
Mark and Devin examine the recent spate of sexual assault and harassment allegations against Hollywood superproducer Harvey Weinstein. They consider how such heinous crimes could have been permitted to continue for more than three decades, and what this escalating news story says about the hidden culture behind the entertainment products they love to consume.
If you want to offer feedback or constructive criticisms about this episode, please reach out on Twitter (@MarkALieberman and @DevinMitchell) or by email. We’re not scholars on these subjects, and we’re eager for comments from perspectives other than our own.
Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey, New York Times, Oct. 5. “Harvey Weinstein Paid Off Sexual Harassment Accusers for Decades.”
Ronan Farrow, New Yorker, Oct. 10. “From Aggressive Overtures to Sexual Assault; Harvey Weinstein’s Accusers Tell Their Stories.”
Jodi Kantor and Rachel Abrams, New York Times, Oct. 10. “Gwyneth Paltrow, Angelina Jolie and Others Say Weinstein Harassed Them.”
Jia Tolentino, New Yorker, Oct. 11. “Harvey Weinstein and the Impunity of Powerful Men.”
Lisa Ryan, Vulture, Oct. 11. “An Exhaustive List of the Allegations Against Harvey Weinstein.”
Lupita Nyong’o, New York Times, Oct. 19. “Speaking Out Against Harvey Weinstein.”
Ronan Farrow, New Yorker, Oct. 27. “Weighing the Costs of Speaking Out Against Harvey Weinstein.”
Chloe Melas, CNN, Oct. 27. “Harvey Weinstein’s New York haunt: Former servers describe tantrums and revolving door of women.”