First, some obligatory awards season perspective: the Oscars don’t matter to you. You’re allowed to like a movie whether it was nominated for Best Picture or not. You are your own Oscars.
If that’s the case, why do we get so worked up about snubs and surprises and predictions and hopes and dreams? We want to see quality work recognized. The Academy Awards are one of the most common starting points for someone looking at the films of a particular year. If the awards don’t reflect the best movies, they’ll provide an inaccurate reflection of what we thought about film in 2013.
Nonetheless, complaining about the Oscar nominations is futile. It’s better to look at them as a starting point for discussions about the merits of movies. In that spirit, I’ve chosen four nominated-related things that made me happy this morning, and four that made me less than happy. Let’s use this list as a way of talking about movies, not awards.
(For more of my thoughts on the subject, stay tuned for this week’s episode of The M&M Report, in which Devin Mitchell and I will talk in depth about the year in movies.)
The first thing to say about the 2014 Screen Actors’ Guild nominations is the same thing that needs to be said about any list of nominations. My personal taste and that of the voting body doesn’t always align. I think some worthy actors got snubbed in favor of some actors who didn’t necessarily need the reward. Whatever. There are worse crimes.
The second thing to say is that the Screen Actors’ Guild Awards are best described as a barometer: of the awards season mania to come, of the preferences of the Screen Actors’ Guild, of the discourse around the year’s most discussed movies and television shows.
The third thing to say is…there isn’t much to say about the nominations themselves. But I’m going to say some things anyway.
I’ve already complained about the clunky telecast for the 2014 Grammy nominations in my piece for The Eagle. Nonetheless, I have a few more thoughts (three, in fact) on the nominations in general.
First, to quote from my piece:
“Despite some oversights, the nominations reflected the wide, if scattered, range of excellent pop music in 2013. Rising country star Kacey Musgraves nabbed three well-deserved nominations including one for Best New Artist. The Grammys embraced the anti-establishment alternative hip-hop of Lorde and the irrepressible smooth of Daft Punk. Taylor Swift’s excellent album Red ended up in the Album of the Year category, suggesting that the Grammys have longer memories than they are given credit for.”
Read on for three more thoughts.